Skip to main content
H 8401Insurance

Insurance - Unauthorized Insurance Business - Medical Malpractice Insurance

The bill requires all Rhode Island healthcare providers to maintain state-approved medical malpractice insurance to keep their medical licenses.

Held for study
Population
Affected
35
Introduced Apr 3, 2026Committee House Corporations

Plain-English Summary

This bill requires all hospitals, physicians, and healthcare providers in Rhode Island to carry medical malpractice insurance that is strictly regulated and approved by the Department of Business Regulation (DBR). It allows hospitals affiliated with medical schools to create their own self-insurance programs, provided they prove they are financially stable, have adequate reserves to pay out claims, and can survive a hospital's bankruptcy. The bill ensures that healthcare providers cannot maintain their medical licenses unless they have this approved malpractice coverage.

For younger readers

When doctors and hospitals make a mistake that hurts a patient, they need a special type of insurance to help pay for the patient's care. This bill makes a new rule that all doctors and hospitals must have this insurance. A state department will check the insurance companies to make sure they actually have enough money saved up to pay for those mistakes. If a doctor or hospital doesn't have this approved insurance, they will not be allowed to work.

Who & Where It Applies

Impacted groups
HospitalsPhysiciansHealthcare providersMedical malpractice insurersPatients
Impacted communities
All

Constitutional & Fiscal Check

None Likely. The state has well-established police powers to regulate public health, safety, and the insurance industry. Mandating liability insurance as a condition for professional licensure is a standard regulatory practice and does not typically violate due process, free speech, or protection against unreasonable searches.

Estimated cost
None
Estimated revenue
Amount unknown

Bill Analysis

Both viewpoints
For Progressives
  • Ensures that hospitals and healthcare providers have adequate, state-regulated financial reserves to compensate patients who are victims of medical malpractice.
  • Increases government oversight and transparency over corporate hospital self-insurance programs, preventing them from evading accountability during bankruptcies.
  • Protects the community by tying medical licensing directly to the maintenance of approved liability coverage, ensuring only responsible providers can practice.
  • Stricter insurance regulations and capitalization requirements could increase operating costs for healthcare providers, which may be passed on to marginalized patients.
  • The heavy financial burden of establishing state-approved captive insurance entities might disproportionately favor large, wealthy hospital networks over smaller community clinics.
  • Could lead to a reduction of available healthcare providers in underserved areas if doctors lose their licenses due to temporary lapses in the newly regulated malpractice coverage.
For Conservatives
  • Promotes fiscal responsibility by requiring self-insured hospitals to prove actuarial soundness and adequate capitalization, reducing the risk of insolvency.
  • Establishes clear, uniform, statewide standards for medical malpractice insurance, providing regulatory certainty for the healthcare industry.
  • Ensures that self-insurance entities will survive hospital bankruptcies, protecting creditors and preventing potential taxpayer bailouts for unpaid medical liabilities.
  • Imposes heavy government interference and strict regulatory burdens on hospitals attempting to manage their own risk through self-insurance.
  • Grants broad, centralized power to the state government to dictate the terms, limits, and deductibles of private insurance contracts.
  • Threatens corporate freedom by tying the fundamental right to practice medicine to strict, state-mandated insurance requirements.

Votes

Loading votes...

Full Bill Text

Changes to existing Rhode Island law · 113 additions · 60 deletions

SECTION 1. Section 27-16-2.6 of the General Laws in Chapter 27-16 entitled "Unauthorized Insurance Business" is hereby amended to read as follows: 27-16-2.6. Hospitals affiliated with accredited medical schools — Indemnification of personnel Self-insurance for hospitals affiliated with accredited medical schools. Nothing in §§ 27-16-1.2 — 27-16-2.2 shall be construed to limit or prevent hospitals affiliated with an accredited medical school from agreeing to indemnify hospital employees, and physicians, including physicians’ incorporated or unincorporated practices and employees, and medical, nursing, or allied health students affiliated with the hospital, collectively “covered persons”, for the legal liability of those covered persons for loss, damage, or expense incident to claims of bodily injury or death arising out of medical malpractice or professional error or mistake, “malpractice coverage”, whether the hospital charges the covered persons for malpractice coverage or not. The hospitals making the agreements shall be required to establish and maintain a reserve fund with which the malpractice coverage will be provided, which may be either part of or separate from a self-insurance fund maintained by or on behalf of the hospital. Any self-insurance fund shall annually provide a certified financial statement with actuarial projections as to the soundness of its reserving to the director of the department of health and the director of the department of business regulation. The malpractice coverage provided by the agreements shall be in amounts that meet the minimum insurance coverage limits required by any regulation promulgated by the director of business regulation pursuant to § 42-14.1-2.

(a) Notwithstanding any provision of law, rule or regulation to the contrary, any hospital affiliated with a Rhode Island accredited medical school may establish a self-insurance program for medical malpractice liability; provided, however, that such program shall be subject to the full regulatory authority, review, and approval of the department of business regulation.

(b) No such self-insurance program shall be established, maintained, or operated without prior approval of the department of business regulation.

(c) The department of business regulation shall require demonstration of:

(1) Establishment of an entity, such as a captive insurance company, that is regulated as an insurance entity;

(2) Actuarial soundness of the entity;

(3) Adequate capitalization and reserves;

(4) Claims-paying ability under reasonably foreseeable adverse conditions;

(5) Ongoing financial reporting and independent audit; and

(6) The hospital entity will establish to the satisfaction of the department of business regulation that the self-insurance entities existence and reserves will survive the bankruptcy, dissolution or reorganization of the hospital. (d)(1) The department shall have authority to examine, audit, and require corrective action, including suspension or revocation of approval in the same manner in which the department has authority over licensed insurers under title 27.

(2) If the self-insured entity is domiciled outside of Rhode Island, the department of business regulation shall be given access to all records of the entity and of the foreign jurisdiction regarding the entity upon demand.

(e) The hospital will be responsible for all costs incurred by the department of business regulation pursuant to § 27-13.1-7.

(f) The provisions of § 27-13.1-5(f) shall apply to all information received or created by the department of business regulation in regulation of the self-insured entity.

(g) Any exemption from traditional insurance requirements under this section shall not exempt such entities from solvency, reporting, or oversight requirements imposed by the department of business regulation.

(h) No medical malpractice coverage provided under this section shall be recognized for purposes of licensure unless approved by the department of business regulation.

(i) The department of business regulation may withdraw approval of the self-insurance entity if the department determines that the entity is in hazardous financial condition pursuant to chapter 14.2 of title 27 or is otherwise out of compliance with this statute.

(j) The department of business regulation shall prescribe the manner of application for permissible self-insurance and shall require renewal of the permission to self-insure on an annual basis.

(k) If a hospital that has been granted self-insured status, a general description of the self- insured entity, including all contact information, shall be public along with information pursuant to § 27-13.1-5(e). All other information provided to the department of business regulation shall be subject to § 27-13.1-5(f).

SECTION 2. Chapter 27-16 of the General Laws entitled "Unauthorized Insurance Business" is hereby amended by adding thereto the following section: 27-16-2.7. Comprehensive regulation of medical malpractice coverage.

(a) All forms of medical malpractice coverage for Rhode Island licensed providers, including insurance policies, self-insurance programs, captive insurance arrangements, and risk- sharing pools, shall be subject to the exclusive regulatory authority of the department of business regulation.

(b) No such coverage shall be valid for purposes of licensure unless approved by the department of business regulation.

(c) The department shall establish standards for:

(1) Financial solvency;

(2) Reserve adequacy;

(3) Claims-paying ability; and

(4) Governance and risk management.

(d) The department shall have authority to examine, audit, and enforce compliance for all entities providing such coverage.

(e) No form of medical malpractice insurance shall satisfy the requirement of coverage in this statute unless it meets the limits and deductibles established by the department of business regulation by rule or regulation.

(f) The identity of medical malpractice coverage, including the insurer or self-insured entity, policy limits and deductibles shall be provided to the public upon demand.

SECTION 3. Section 42-14-2.1 of the General Laws in Chapter 42-14 entitled "Department of Business Regulation" is hereby amended to read as follows: 42-14-2.1. Reporting by certain insurers — Settlements Reporting of claims and coverage.

(a) Every insurer or entity exempt pursuant to § 27-16-2.6 or entity permissibly self-insured pursuant to § 42-14.1-2 providing professional liability insurance to licensed healthcare professionals or licensed healthcare facilities shall send a complete report to the board of medical licensure and discipline established pursuant to chapter 37 of title 5, or the board of examiners in dentistry established pursuant to chapter 31.1 of title 5 and the department of business regulation as to any claim, notice, settlement, judgment, or arbitration award of a claim or action for damages for death or personal injury caused by such person’s negligence, error, or omission in practice or the person’s rendering of unauthorized professional services. The report shall be sent within thirty

(30) days after service of such arbitration award on the parties or notice of the claim, settlement, judgment, or arbitration award.

(b) Notwithstanding any other provision of law, an insurer or entity exempt pursuant to § 27-16-2.6 or entity permissibly self-insured pursuant to § 42-14.1-2 providing professional liability coverage to licensed healthcare professionals or licensed healthcare facilities shall have the contractual right to settle any claim up to the limits of the policy without the insured’s consent, unless the policy by its express terms prohibits the insurer from settling any claim without the consent of the insured.

(c) All insurers doing business in the state of Rhode Island or entity exempt pursuant to § 27-16-2.6 or entity permissibly self-insured pursuant to § 42-14.1-2 providing professional liability insurance for healthcare professionals or licensed healthcare facilities shall file an annual report with the commissioner of insurance. This report must be filed for each year by March 1 of the next year. The information required for each year shall include, for each rating class:

(1) The number of insured;

(2) The total premiums paid;

(3) The total number of claims made, the years in which the incidents giving rise to the claims occurred, and the total number of those claims outstanding at the end of the year;

(4) The total amount of claims paid, the years in which the incidents giving rise to the claims occurred, and the amount of the costs that can be identified with these claims for investigation, processing, and defense of these claims; and

(5) The number of lawsuits filed.

(a) All insurers, self-insurance programs, captive arrangements, risk retention groups, or any entity providing professional liability coverage to Rhode Island licensed providers shall provide all information requested by the department of business regulation regarding their financial status, claims and coverage.

(b) The information shall include, but not be limited to:

(1) Claims activity;

(2) Coverage limits and structure;

(3) Financial condition of the coverage provider; and

(4) Actuarial reserve status for self-insured programs.

(c) Reporting shall occur as directed by the department of business regulation.

(d) The department of business regulation shall have the authority to require additional financial and actuarial reporting necessary to assess solvency.

(e) The department of business regulation shall share data and coordinate enforcement actions with the department of health or with other jurisdictions in accordance with § 27-13.1- 5(e)(2).

(f) The provisions of § 27-13.1-5(f) shall apply to all information received or created by the department of business regulation in regulation of the self-insured entity.

(g) Any material impairment, insolvency risk, or regulatory action identified by the department of business regulation shall be reported to the department of health and may trigger licensure review or action.

(h) In addition to any action taken by the department of health, the department of business regulation may take action against the self-insurance entity pursuant to § 27-13.1-5(d) independent of any action taken by the department of health.

(i) If the department of business regulation believes that the solvency of the self-insured entity is at risk, it may take action against the self-insured entity under the provisions of § 27-13.1- 5(d).

(j) The hospital will be responsible for all costs incurred by the department of business regulation pursuant to § 27-13.1-7.

SECTION 4. Section 42-14.1-2 of the General Laws in Chapter 42-14.1 entitled "Department of Business Regulation — Medical Malpractice Insurance" is hereby amended to read as follows: 42-14.1-2. Malpractice insurance Professional liability insurance required.

(a) The director of business regulation shall promulgate rules and regulations requiring all licensed medical and dental professional and all licensed healthcare providers to be covered by professional liability insurance insuring the practitioner for claims of bodily injury or death arising out of malpractice, professional error, or mistake. The director of the department of business regulation is hereby authorized to promulgate regulations establishing the minimum insurance coverage limits that shall be required; provided, however, that such limits shall not be less than one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) for claims arising out of the same professional service and three hundred thousand dollars ($300,000) in the aggregate. The director of the department of business regulation is further authorized to establish rules and regulations allowing persons or entities with sufficient financial resources to be self-insurers.

(b) Every licensed healthcare provider in direct patient care within a licensed hospital shall obtain liability insurance in a minimum amount determined by the board of trustees of that hospital.

(a) Every physician, hospital, and healthcare provider shall maintain professional liability coverage as a condition of licensure.

(b) Such coverage shall be obtained from:

(1) An insurer licensed or approved by the department of business regulation; or

(2) A self-insurance entity expressly approved by the department of business regulation pursuant to the provisions of title 27.

(c) The department of health shall not issue, renew, or maintain any license unless proof of such approved coverage is provided.

(d) The department of health shall not recognize, approve, or accept any form of professional liability coverage that has not been reviewed and approved by the department of business regulation.

(e) Any lapse, suspension, or revocation of such coverage shall constitute grounds for licensure action, including suspension or revocation by the department of health.

SECTION 5. Section 23-17-6 of the General Laws in Chapter 23-17 entitled "Licensing of Healthcare Facilities" is hereby amended to read as follows: 23-17-6. Issuance of license — Posting — Transfer — Conditions.

(a) Upon receipt of an application for a license, the licensing agency shall issue a license if the applicant and healthcare facility meet the requirements established under this chapter and any rules and regulations that may be established in accordance with the requirements established under this chapter. A license issued under the provisions of this section shall be the property of the state and loaned to the licensee, and it shall be kept posted in a conspicuous place on the licensed premises. Each license shall be issued only for the premises and persons named in the application, and shall not be transferable or assignable except with the written approval of the licensing agency. Home nursing-care providers and home-care providers operating under a single license may establish branch offices under that same single license and that license shall be maintained and posted in the central office.

(b) Any change in owner, operator, or lessee of a licensed healthcare facility, (except for single-practice physician ambulatory-surgery centers, multi-practice physician ambulatory-surgery centers, single-practice podiatry ambulatory-surgery centers and multi-practice podiatry ambulatory-surgery centers as defined in subsections (17) and (18) of chapter 17, section 2) which license shall be transferable or assignable by decision of the licensing agency as shall be provided by regulation, shall require prior review by the health services council and approval of the licensing agency as a condition precedent to the transfer, assignment, or issuance of a new license. Issuance of the license may be made subject to any condition; provided, that no condition may be made unless it directly relates to the statutory purpose expressed in § 23-17-3 or to the review criteria set forth in § 23-17-14.3. This shall not limit the authority of the licensing agency to require correction of conditions or defects which existed prior to the proposed change of owner, operator, or lessee and of which notice had been given to the healthcare facility by the licensing agency.

(c) Issuance of the license shall be conditioned on obtaining and maintaining a medical malpractice policy in compliance with § 42-14.1-2 or otherwise being in compliance with § 27-16- 2.6. If a healthcare facility license fails to maintain such coverage, its license may be denied, suspended or revoked pursuant to § 23-17-8.

SECTION 6. This act shall take effect on January 1, 2027.