Skip to main content
H 7936Public Health

Health and Safety - Public Health Data Privacy and Protection Act

This bill mandates that personal disease and health data collected by the state remains confidential and off-limits to the public.

Held for study
Population
Affected
45
Introduced Feb 27, 2026Committee House Health & Human Services

Plain-English Summary

This legislation establishes the "Public Health Data Privacy and Protection Act." It classifies specific disease data collected by the Rhode Island Department of Health as confidential and exempt from public records requests. The bill grants the Department of Health sole authority to release this data, limiting disclosure strictly to public health purposes, such as controlling outbreaks or approved research. It prohibits sharing this data for lawsuits or commercial use. Additionally, it outlines rules for sharing immunization records with schools and healthcare providers while adhering to privacy laws.

For younger readers

Imagine you went to the doctor because you were sick. This bill makes sure that the notes the doctor sends to the government stay a secret. It creates a rule that says strangers, businesses, or people who are just curious cannot look at your private health information. Only special health workers who are trying to stop germs from spreading, or your own doctors and school nurses, are allowed to see it. It helps make sure your private business stays private, so no one knows your medical history unless they are there to help you.

Who & Where It Applies

Impacted groups
PatientsHealthcare ProvidersResearchersDepartment of HealthStudents
Impacted communities
All

Constitutional & Fiscal Check

The provision declaring that data cannot be subpoenaed except as authorized by the Department of Health potentially violates the Separation of Powers doctrine by infringing on the Judiciary's power to compel evidence. It may also implicate Due Process if it prevents litigants from accessing necessary exculpatory evidence. However, privacy protections for medical data are generally upheld as a compelling state interest.

Estimated cost
None
Estimated revenue
None

Bill Analysis

Both viewpoints
For Progressives
  • Protects the privacy of individuals with stigmatized health conditions, preventing potential discrimination against vulnerable populations who rely on state health services.
  • Prevents the commercialization of personal health data, ensuring that private corporations cannot access and exploit sensitive medical histories for profit.
  • Strengthens community trust in public health institutions by guaranteeing confidentiality, which encourages marginalized groups to seek testing and treatment without fear of exposure.
  • Exempts this data from public records, which could reduce transparency and make it harder for journalists or watchdogs to hold the Department of Health accountable for failures.
  • Centralizes total authority over data release within a single state department, potentially creating a bottleneck for independent researchers studying systemic health inequalities.
  • Limits the ability of legal advocates to subpoena data that might be necessary to prove environmental or systemic causes of illness in class-action lawsuits.
For Conservatives
  • Protects the private medical information of citizens from being accessed by the media or general public through government records requests.
  • Prevents trial lawyers from using subpoenas to access private health data for litigation fishing expeditions, reducing legal liabilities.
  • Ensures that private citizens' health data is not treated as a commodity to be used for commercial purposes or marketing.
  • Consolidates power within an unelected bureaucratic agency (Department of Health) by granting it "sole authority" over data release without external checks and balances.
  • Codifies the sharing of immunization records with various government agencies and schools, which may be viewed as government overreach into family privacy.
  • Allows the state to share de-identified data with federal agencies like the CDC without requiring explicit, ongoing consent from the individuals involved.

Votes

Loading votes...

Full Bill Text

Changes to existing Rhode Island law · 78 additions

It is enacted by the General Assembly as follows:

SECTION 1. Title 23 of the General Laws entitled "HEALTH AND SAFETY" is hereby amended by adding thereto the following chapter: 23-106-1. Definitions. For purposes of this chapter:

(1) “De-identified data” means data from which identifiers have been removed in accordance with applicable state and federal standards such that the data cannot reasonably be used to identify an individual.

(2) “Line-level data” means reportable disease data that includes direct or indirect identifiers, or that can reasonably be used to identify an individual case, contact, or reporting entity. Individual-level or line-level data can also be known as record-level data.

(3) “Public health purpose” means activities necessary to prevent or control disease, injury, or disability including, but not limited to public health surveillance, investigation, outbreak response, intervention, and evaluation.

(4) “Reportable disease data” means any information, record, laboratory result, medical record, or other data collected or maintained by Rhode Island department of health (“department”) pursuant to state law or regulation for the purpose of disease reporting, surveillance, investigation, control, or prevention. 23-106-2. Confidentiality of reportable disease data.

(a) All reportable disease data, including line-level data, in the possession or control of the department shall be confidential and shall not be considered a public record.

(b) Such data shall not be disclosed, subpoenaed, or otherwise released except as expressly authorized in § 23-106-3 or as required by federal law.

(c) The confidentiality protections in this section apply regardless of the format of the data, including paper records, electronic records, and databases. 23-106-3. Authority and permitted releases.

(a) The Rhode Island department of health is the sole authority responsible for determining access to, confidentiality of, and release of reportable disease data. No other state agency, political subdivision, or entity shall release reportable disease line-level data without written authorization by the department.

(b) The department may release de-identified reportable disease line-level data only when necessary for a public health purpose, including:

(1) Sharing with other local, state, tribal, territorial, or federal public health authorities (including the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention) for surveillance, investigation, or control activities;

(2) Sharing with healthcare facilities, laboratories, or providers as needed for case management, outbreak control, or prevention;

(3) Sharing with researchers or partners pursuant to a department-approved data use agreement that limits use to a public health purpose and prohibits re-identification or re-disclosure; or

(4) As otherwise required by federal law.

(c) The department may release de-identified data or aggregate statistical reports when the department determines such release is in the public interest and does not create a reasonable risk of re-identification. 23-106-4. Limitations on disclosure.

(a) Line-level reportable disease data shall not be released for purposes unrelated to public health, including litigation, commercial purposes, or general public records requests.

(b) Any recipient of line-level data must comply with department conditions for use, security, retention, and destruction, as set forth in a department data use agreement or equivalent written instrument.

(c) Persons authorized by the director may conduct research studies pursuant to 216 RICR 30-05-1; provided, however, that the researcher shall submit a written request for information, shall execute a research agreement that protects the confidentiality of the information provided and obtain any relative human subjects approval.

(d) The department may enter into collaborative agreements with registries of states and exchange individual or group information provided that maximum protections are afforded the confidentiality of citizens of Rhode Island in accordance with state law.

(e) Immunization information, obtained pursuant to § 23-1-44, shall only be released from the immunization registry to the following individuals and agencies, unless the registrant, or the parent or guardian if the registrant is a minor, objects to such disclosure. All such disclosures shall comply with the privacy protections of chapter 37.3 of title 5 and the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996, Pub. L. No. 104-191 (HIPAA), as amended and all other applicable state and federal laws:

(1) Licensed health care providers providing direct care to the registrant-patient;

(2) Elementary and secondary school nurses and institutions of higher education, and registration officials who require proof of immunization for school enrollment and disease control;

(3) State Women Infants and Children, or WIC, nutrition program staff who administer WIC benefits to eligible infants and children;

(4) Staff of state agencies or state programs whose duties include education and outreach related to the improvement of immunization coverage rates;

(5) Health plans for immunization rate improvement and quality improvement efforts; and

(6) Any other entity with the express written consent of the registrant or the registrant’s parent or guardian if the registrant is a minor.

(f) Notwithstanding the provisions of subsection (e) of this section;

(1) Persons authorized by the director may conduct research studies pursuant to § 23-1- 18(10); provided, however, the researcher shall submit a written request for information, shall execute a research agreement that protects the confidentiality of the information provided, and obtain any relative human subject’s approval.

(2) The department may enter into collaborative agreements with registries of other states and exchange individual or group information provided that maximum protections are afforded the confidentiality of registrant information in accordance with state and federal law.

SECTION 2. This act shall take effect upon passage.